Vantara Familiarization Visit & Assessment
A Follow-up Take on Conservation, Controversies, and Reforms
This is my follow-up assessment of Vantara after my recent visit. It contrasts in some ways with my earlier assessments, my submission to the Supreme Court, and the information published on my webpage. I classified this visit as giving the “right to respond", a practice I have followed in all my documentaries and other media exposés.
When the first Supreme Court case was launched, the lawyer who filed it asked me to present my evidence. I did so. His feedback is reproduced below:
"With great respect, I am glad to see your mail. You did wonderful work; it is not too easy to make such work. I printed all your mails and submitted them as evidence before the SIT formed by the Supreme Court. They spent several hours reviewing your synopsis and documents and accepted them as evidence.
Thank you for your unbelievable support.
Wishing you to continue journeying to save the world.
C.R. JAYA SUKIN"
The disappointing part was that, in the end, none of what I presented was referenced in the ruling. However, there is little doubt that these submissions reached Vantara's executives, who therefore knew my concerns and where I stood before inviting me to visit.
Turning to the new status quo, the recently installed oversight committee produced a detailed voluntary commitment that reflects the CITES Secretariat's requests, made through the CITES Standing Committee (see August 19, 2026 letter to CITES), for India to adopt stricter due-diligence procedures. That resolution was ultimately voted down at the Samarkand meeting.
To me, reading between the lines of the voluntary commitments, this already amounted in many ways to confirmation that there had been question marks regarding the acquisition process of imported wildlife and a commitment to meaningful change. That impression was reinforced during my meeting with the Vantara team and Mr. Anant Ambani, who stated again that, in response to the continued questions and criticism, they had decided to stop importing exotic species and instead focus on conservation and animal-welfare issues in India and other conservation hotspots. In doing so, they would effectively extend the original moratorium announced in the new voluntary commitments.
However, I found myself arguing for limited exceptions considered acceptable based on what I saw in the case of Coco, a young chimpanzee receiving intensive care. Vantara representatives reportedly encountered her in the UAE after she had apparently suffered a stroke. I have asked for the full story. She was flown to Vantara and admitted to a highly sophisticated intensive-care unit. Partially paralyzed, she has full-time keepers who monitor her vital signs, feed her, change her diapers, and attend to her other needs. When I began communicating with her in chimp grunts, she responded and would not stop.
There was little doubt that this was a genuine rescue. I cannot think of another facility or institution that would have taken her in while also accepting the associated financial responsibilities. To me, it also demonstrated that one of Mr. Anant's and Vantara's guiding principles, "Every life matters", is being actively implemented on the ground.

My visit with Coco and her doctors.
The scale of the Vantara operation is mind-blowing, and my ageing brain could not absorb everything the dozens of experts at each exhibit explained and presented. But it was Coco’s story that led me to suggest amending the "no more imports" policy to allow carefully defined exceptions for clearly compassionate cases like hers. Whether that is appropriate in the context of human needs and suffering in so many parts of the world is a separate discussion, one that would require a broader forum and careful consideration of corresponding cultural and ethical values.
I therefore hope Vantara/Greens can elevate Coco's story beyond the broader discussions and controversies, telling it in detail and providing regular, maybe YouTube, updates on her progress, with relevant medical experts explaining developments. Her attendants could share new observations and test additional forms of enrichment, for example by showing chimpanzee videos on a large screen and monitoring her responses. I understand this is now being explored.
Although a four-day visit did not allow one to see all the holding facilities, which are spread over a very large area (the head veterinarian explained that on some days he drove some 200 kilometers to get to all his charges). As such, it would be far-fetched to select any single animal and suggest that its history is fully representative of what Vantara stands for. While Coco's case is clearly not representative of the conservation dimensions associated with this venture, from an animal-welfare perspective it went far beyond anything I expected or had encountered elsewhere.
Given the number, scale, and distribution of the facilities and supporting infrastructure, I assume I saw only a fraction of the overall operation. Before the visit, however, I was asked which species I wanted to see. I provided a list that included the apes, the big cats, and the shoebill storks from the DRC, which are unlikely to breed in captivity, so in conservation value terms possibly a dead end. I was shown all of them, although there may be scope to expand this kind of inspection and familiarization exercise.
I know that many readers who have reached this point will now place me in the "bunny hugger" camp, a label I am happy to live with. After this visit, and after considerable discussion and reflection, I am confident that even most of the more traditional conservation actors embarking on similar visits would also conclude that, at this stage, taking the decision to move on may be prudent. This could perhaps be combined with repatriation efforts, including the return of the gorilla from the DRC to a relevant sanctuary in North Kivu.
If this was combined with the proposed in-situ conservation plans, the possibility of this project becoming a net benefit to conservation has to be considered.
Yet I can again hear the critics asking - "What about the animals taken from the wild and brought to Vantara?" This was a central concern in the evidence I submitted to the Supreme Court and in the material I compiled after the hearing and verdict, and some questions remain unanswered.
However, I also observed the daily care provided to more than 200 elephants, many of them clearly ailing and requiring extensive veterinary attention. As in Coco's case, I felt such situations needed to be considered alongside the acquisition controversies.
Stepping back, my overall impression of Vantara/Greens, while recognizing that I may have seen only 10-20% of its total facilities and infrastructure, is that more resources have gone into this operation than into any other zoo or safari park I know of. Its daily operating costs are likely several times those of even the largest zoos operating under the EAZA or AZA umbrella.
Beyond the impressive animal-holding facilities, clearly designed and managed with deep expertise with staff members briefing us extensively on every aspect of their respective roles.
Although some of the animals we saw might have been better off remaining in the wild, others are unquestionably receiving far better care than they did in the places from which they came.
The best way to understand where the conservation and animal-welfare community might ultimately stand on these issues is to invite a wider range of stakeholders, especially critics. In my view, no judgment deserves serious consideration unless it is informed by direct observation and giving key decisionmakers the right to respond. As I have often said, "If you want to know, you have to go." A corresponding policy to invite interested parties now exists.
On our scheduled departure day, I was told that Mr. Anant wanted to meet us at Antilia, the family's well-known high-rise residence in Mumbai. We therefore had to change our flights and the departure from India had to be pushed back.
In our final conversation with Mr. Anant Ambani, he made clear that he believed he was making a significant contribution to conservation and animal welfare. He expressed surprise at the questioning of his motives and at the concerns surrounding their acquisition procedures. He explained that, under the new voluntary commitments, Vantara had already pledged to substantial concessions and reforms, including major investments in in-situ projects worldwide.
He stated on two occasions that they would be willing to consider making the already agreed moratorium a permanent policy. I again referred to cases such as Coco's. The chimpanzee recovering in intensive care and receiving a second chance at life may justify leaving the door open for carefully selected, compassion-based rescues.
I also suggested that he consider serving as a global conservation ambassador, given his unmatched access to policy and decisionmakers in countries containing major conservation hotspots but lacking the resources and political will to address them effectively. He explained that his daily responsibilities as an Executive Director of Reliance Industries leave limited scope for such a role, although making the occasional call would be feasible.
This could involve creating a dedicated audit team or partnering with an established firm such as SGS, which conducts audits for Forest Stewardship Council projects to evaluate future in situ conservation projects to ensure real and lasting impact.
In this context, I was told that future efforts would prioritize direct partnerships with government departments, bypassing the intermediaries who often become involved in wildlife acquisitions and relying instead on public-private partnerships. As an example of a streamlined approach to project evaluation, I shared a link to our documentary on auditing the Gombe Stream chimpanzee conservation project: Click here.
I expect the upcoming Geneva meetings (Eighty-first meeting of the CITES Standing Committee (SC81) to provide further opportunities to build on the recommendations I submitted after my visit. If the parties at the CITES Standing Committee meeting endorse the latest voluntary commitments and compliance mechanism, would validate the proposed way forward and allow planning to begin for the next phase, with an emphasis on in situ conservation and more animal welfare initiatives.